Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Your rating of Yes albums

Collapse
X
Collapse
 
  • Page of 3
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
Previous 1 2 3 template Next
    #1

    Your rating of Yes albums

    I've been looking at ProgArchives lately and it has some interesting ratings for some albums Yes fans usually rate higher.
    So what are your ratings? Give stars 1-5, optionally add fractions if it feels more fair.
    I find this easier than ranking the albums.

    Here's my list:
    Yes (1969) ** 1/2
    ​Time and a Word (1970) ***
    The Yes Album (1971) *****
    ​Fragile (1971) **** 1/2
    Close to the Edge (1972) *****
    Tales From Topographic Oceans (1973) ****
    Relayer (1974) **** 1/2
    ​​​​​Going for the One (1977) *****
    Tormato (1978) ***
    Drama (1980) **** 1/2
    90125 (1983) *** 1/2
    Big Generator (1987) ***
    ABWH (1989) ***
    ​Union (1991) *** 1/2
    Talk (1994) *****
    Keys to Ascension 1 (1996) ****
    Keys to Ascension 2 (1997) *** 1/2
    Open Your Eyes (1997) *** 1/2
    The Ladder (1999) **** 1/2
    Magnification (2001) ***
    Fly From Here (2011) ****
    ​Heaven and Earth (2014) ** 1/2​​​
    From a Page (2019) *** 1/2
    The Quest (2021) ***
    Mirror To The Sky (2023) ****
    Symphony
    Karmachromatic
    It's only static
    The key defines the scale we climb
    To at last perceive we are
    We are contrast in harmony​
    Tags: None
    • Likes 1
    #2
    I give up: too difficult to me.
    I only can say that for me

    Home Tales from Topographic Ocean
    Forum Relayer
    YESmusic Close to the Edge
    # 4 The Yes Album
    Groups Fragile

    Comment

      #3
      well as far as the studio records:

      Yes (1969) 5/10
      ​Time and a Word (1970) 7/10
      The Yes Album (1971) 10/10
      ​Fragile (1971) 10/10
      Close to the Edge (1972) 10/10
      Tales From Topographic Oceans (1973) 8/10
      Relayer (1974) 10/10
      ​​​​​Going for the One (1977) 10/10
      Tormato (1978) 7/10
      Drama (1980) 9/10
      90125 (1983) 9/10
      Big Generator (1987) 9/10
      ABWH (1989) 7/10
      ​Union (1991) 7/10
      Talk (1994) 8/10
      Keys to Ascension 1 (1996) 5/10
      Keys to Ascension 2 (1997) 7/10
      Open Your Eyes (1997) 6/10
      The Ladder (1999) 9/10
      Magnification (2001) 9/10
      Fly From Here (2011) 9/10
      ​Heaven and Earth (2014) 5/10​​
      From a Page (2019) 7/10
      The Quest (2021) 8/10
      Mirror To The Sky (2023) 9/10
      Last edited by soundchaser09; 05-20-2023, 03:48 AM.
      The Definitive YES Albums

      -The Yes Album-Fragile-Close to the Edge-Tales From Topographic Oceans-
      -Relayer-Going for the One-Drama-90125-Big Generator-Talk-
      -The Ladder-Magnification-Fly From Here-The Quest-Mirror to the Sky-
      • Likes 2

      Comment

        #4
        Tens across the board!

        Comment

          #5


          Yes (1969) 4
          ​Time and a Word (1970) 5
          The Yes Album (1971) 9
          ​Fragile (1971) 9
          Close to the Edge (1972) 10
          Tales From Topographic Oceans (1973) 8
          Relayer (1974) 10
          ​​​​​Going for the One (1977) 7
          Tormato (1978)7
          Drama (1980) 10
          90125 (1983) 8
          Big Generator (1987)8
          ABWH (1989) 7
          ​Union (1991)8
          Talk (1994) 8
          Keys to Ascension 1 studio tracks(1996) 1
          Keys to Ascension 2 studio tracks(1997) 7
          Open Your Eyes (1997) 6
          The Ladder (1999) 7
          Magnification (2001) 6
          Fly From Here (2011)9
          ​Heaven and Earth (2014) 5
          From a Page (2019) 6
          The Quest (2021) 1
          Mirror To The Sky (2023) 2
          • Likes 2

          Comment

            #6
            Originally posted by pjt View Post
            I've been looking at ProgArchives lately and it has some interesting ratings for some albums Yes fans usually rate higher.
            So what are your ratings? Give stars 1-5, optionally add fractions if it feels more fair.
            I find this easier than ranking the albums.

            Here's my list:
            Yes (1969) ** 1/2
            ​Time and a Word (1970) ***
            The Yes Album (1971) *****
            ​Fragile (1971) **** 1/2
            Close to the Edge (1972) *****
            Tales From Topographic Oceans (1973) ****
            Relayer (1974) **** 1/2
            ​​​​​Going for the One (1977) *****
            Tormato (1978) ***
            Drama (1980) **** 1/2
            90125 (1983) *** 1/2
            Big Generator (1987) ***
            ABWH (1989) ***
            ​Union (1991) *** 1/2
            Talk (1994) *****
            Keys to Ascension 1 (1996) ****
            Keys to Ascension 2 (1997) *** 1/2
            Open Your Eyes (1997) *** 1/2
            The Ladder (1999) **** 1/2
            Magnification (2001) ***
            Fly From Here (2011) ****
            ​Heaven and Earth (2014) ** 1/2​​​
            From a Page (2019) *** 1/2
            The Quest (2021) ***
            Mirror To The Sky (2023) ****
            Is this a rating in just the “yesworld” against yes lps alone? And not vs the breadth of music?

            Comment

              #7
              Originally posted by pjt View Post
              I've been looking at ProgArchives lately and it has some interesting ratings for some albums Yes fans usually rate higher.
              So what are your ratings? Give stars 1-5, optionally add fractions if it feels more fair.
              I find this easier than ranking the albums.

              Here's my list:
              Yes (1969) ** 1/2
              ​Time and a Word (1970) ***
              The Yes Album (1971) *****
              ​Fragile (1971) **** 1/2
              Close to the Edge (1972) *****
              Tales From Topographic Oceans (1973) ****
              Relayer (1974) **** 1/2
              ​​​​​Going for the One (1977) *****
              Tormato (1978) ***
              Drama (1980) **** 1/2
              90125 (1983) *** 1/2
              Big Generator (1987) ***
              ABWH (1989) ***
              ​Union (1991) *** 1/2
              Talk (1994) *****
              Keys to Ascension 1 (1996) ****
              Keys to Ascension 2 (1997) *** 1/2
              Open Your Eyes (1997) *** 1/2
              The Ladder (1999) **** 1/2
              Magnification (2001) ***
              Fly From Here (2011) ****
              ​Heaven and Earth (2014) ** 1/2​​​
              From a Page (2019) *** 1/2
              The Quest (2021) ***
              Mirror To The Sky (2023) ****
              No one cares.,
              • Likes 1

              Comment

                #8
                Originally posted by yamishogun View Post

                No one cares.,
                Yet, you're still here....
                • Likes 1

                Comment

                  #9
                  Yes (1969) **
                  ​Time and a Word (1970) **
                  The Yes Album (1971) *****
                  ​Fragile (1971) ****
                  Close to the Edge (1972) *****
                  Tales From Topographic Oceans (1973) *****
                  Relayer (1974) *****
                  ​​​​​Going for the One (1977) ****
                  Tormato (1978) *
                  Drama (1980) *****
                  90125 (1983) *
                  Big Generator (1987)
                  ABWH (1989)
                  ​Union (1991)
                  Talk (1994) *****
                  Keys to Ascension 1 (1996) ***
                  Keys to Ascension 2 (1997) ***
                  Open Your Eyes (1997) ****
                  The Ladder (1999) ****
                  Magnification (2001) **
                  Fly From Here (2011) ***
                  ​Heaven and Earth (2014) **
                  From a Page (2019) **
                  The Quest (2021) **
                  Mirror To The Sky (2023) ****
                  ​
                  • Likes 2

                  Comment

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Mr. Holland View Post

                    Yet, you're still here....
                    Yes Fans' hall monitor....
                    • Likes 1

                    Comment

                      #11
                      Yes (1969) 3
                      ​Time and a Word (1970) 3
                      The Yes Album (1971) 9
                      ​Fragile (1971) 9
                      Close to the Edge (1972) 10
                      Tales From Topographic Oceans (1973) 7 1/2
                      Relayer (1974) 7
                      ​​​​​Going for the One (1977) 9
                      Tormato (1978)7 1/2
                      Drama (1980) 10
                      90125 (1983) 6
                      Big Generator (1987)6
                      ABWH (1989) 5
                      ​Union (1991)5
                      Talk (1994) 6
                      Keys to Ascension 1 studio tracks(1996) 5
                      Keys to Ascension 2 studio tracks(1997) 5
                      Open Your Eyes (1997) 5
                      The Ladder (1999) 4
                      Magnification (2001) 5
                      Fly From Here (2011)4
                      ​Heaven and Earth (2014) 1
                      From a Page (2019) 2
                      The Quest (2021) 1
                      Mirror To The Sky (2023) 1

                      Comment

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Enlighten View Post
                        Yes (1969) 3
                        ​Time and a Word (1970) 3
                        The Yes Album (1971) 9
                        ​Fragile (1971) 9
                        Close to the Edge (1972) 10
                        Tales From Topographic Oceans (1973) 7 1/2
                        Relayer (1974) 7
                        ​​​​​Going for the One (1977) 9
                        Tormato (1978)7 1/2
                        Drama (1980) 10
                        90125 (1983) 6
                        Big Generator (1987)6
                        ABWH (1989) 5
                        ​Union (1991)5
                        Talk (1994) 6
                        Keys to Ascension 1 studio tracks(1996) 5
                        Keys to Ascension 2 studio tracks(1997) 5
                        Open Your Eyes (1997) 5
                        The Ladder (1999) 4
                        Magnification (2001) 5
                        Fly From Here (2011)4
                        ​Heaven and Earth (2014) 1
                        From a Page (2019) 2
                        The Quest (2021) 1
                        Mirror To The Sky (2023) 1
                        Damn....I wouldn't want you as my teacher....😁
                        • Likes 1

                        Comment

                          #13
                          Originally posted by yamishogun View Post

                          No one cares.,
                          I do.
                          • Likes 1

                          Comment

                            #14
                            I stand corrected.

                            Comment

                              #15
                              Originally posted by patrickq View Post
                              I do.
                              I find it fun(!!) to read the responses. 👍

                              Comment

                              Previous 1 2 3 template Next
                              Working...
                              X