Before people flat out say no let me point out the arguments for considering Abwh and ARW as yes could be used for Circa… so here is my case
1. The album had one original yes member one member who was important in the 70’s and one who while not to everyone’s flavor was important to the band in the 80’s and 90’s … and I am not talking about ARW but it sort of Sounds like I am right?
alan was more crucial in the 70’s then many give him credit for
Tony was an original member
billy was crucial to the late 80’s and 90’s saving the band from death similar to Rabin
2. They played yes music live:
they did a 32 minute medley going from the first album - the ladder they also did the more we live let go off union
3. The album sounds like yes: honestly this feels of the same ilk as Drama or the modern albums if Anderson was singing everyone would consider it yes but because it’s a different singer
4. Tony Kaye famously said “if yes won’t go out and do this we will” at the time yes was in hiatus Jon Anderson couldn’t be bothered to rejoin and Squire and White just didn’t have a direction (Steve perry was briefly considered talk about a lack of direction)
this is my argument
thoughts?
1. The album had one original yes member one member who was important in the 70’s and one who while not to everyone’s flavor was important to the band in the 80’s and 90’s … and I am not talking about ARW but it sort of Sounds like I am right?
alan was more crucial in the 70’s then many give him credit for
Tony was an original member
billy was crucial to the late 80’s and 90’s saving the band from death similar to Rabin
2. They played yes music live:
they did a 32 minute medley going from the first album - the ladder they also did the more we live let go off union
3. The album sounds like yes: honestly this feels of the same ilk as Drama or the modern albums if Anderson was singing everyone would consider it yes but because it’s a different singer
4. Tony Kaye famously said “if yes won’t go out and do this we will” at the time yes was in hiatus Jon Anderson couldn’t be bothered to rejoin and Squire and White just didn’t have a direction (Steve perry was briefly considered talk about a lack of direction)
this is my argument
thoughts?
Comment